Hi from Savannah, GA, USA

Welcome sir,
Always good to see more and more Diy guys joining forum.

Any specific reason most speaker manufacturers are moving away electrostats?

Our own Indian company called Cadence used to make hybrid electrostat speakers have stopped making it as well
 
Welcome sir,
Always good to see more and more Diy guys joining forum.

Any specific reason most speaker manufacturers are moving away electrostats?

Our own Indian company called Cadence used to make hybrid electrostat speakers have stopped making it as well

Actually, most speaker manufacturer's have never moved into building ESLs. I think a better question might be; why?
I can think up several reasons why the demand would be higher for conventional speakers:

1. ESLs are inefficient and are a capacitive load that many amps can't survive (this alone rules out half the market).
2. Full range ESLs generally have anemic bass.
3. With few exceptions; most hybrid ESLs fail to achieve a seamless blending of the woofer and ESL panel.
4. ESLs are more prone to failure (corrosion and high-voltage arcing) with exposure to dust & humidity.
5. If an ESL fails, it's not easily fixed (you can't just remove a faulty driver and substitute an aftermarket one).
6. On average, ESLs cost more to make and buy.
7. Most ESLs (even curved panels) have a more beamy and smaller sweet spot that some people don't like.

Avoiding the problems noted above drove the design of my homebuilt ESLs (below).
The insulated wire stators are essentially arc-proof, the 15-segment phased wire arrays electrically curve the wave front to emulate a line source projecting a cylindrical pattern, the electrical segmentation scheme presents an easier, mostly resistive load to the amplifier, and the OB woofer matches the phasing and dipole dispersion of the ESL to achieve a seamless blend.

I did fail miserably on cost and labor though-- they're not cheap and the labor is ridiculous. But I wouldn't trade my speakers for any others I've ever heard.

IMG_2268.jpg
 
Last edited:
wow, they look magnifique, and sure they must be sounding great as well. What amp/amps do you drive them with?
 
wow, they look magnifique, and sure they must be sounding great as well. What amp/amps do you drive them with?
Thanks for kind comments.

My hybrid ESL's + Ripole subs are a six-channel stereo system driven by a DBX Driverack Venu 360 DSP/crossover feeding three Carver TFM-25 (225 W/Ch) stereo amps.

I been focusing on ESLs for 14 years now, and I've dubbed this design the Jazzman MkIII because they have my third-generation wire stators. As time permits, I will post a write up in the DIY section with photos and videos of the build process.
 
Last edited:
For excellent sound that won't break the bank, the 5 Star Award Winning Wharfedale Diamond 12.1 Bookshelf Speakers is the one to consider!
Back
Top