• Hello and Welcome to HiFiVision.com - an online community for the home entertainment and tech enthusiasts!

    If you would like to ask a question, participate in a discussion and view attachments please Register yourself.

Which TV you own? LCD or Plasma?

Wharfedale Diamond 11.1 & 11.2 Speakers

Which TV you own? LCD or Plasma?

  • LCD

    Votes: 6 28.6%
  • Plasma

    Votes: 8 38.1%
  • LCD Full HD

    Votes: 7 33.3%
  • Plasma Full HD

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    21

selective

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2008
Messages
36
Points
6
Location
Bangalore
As the dedate is on and will go on forever between LCD and Plasma, just to check the reality on which technology is being sold mostly lets have the poll.
 

adder

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
2,571
Points
83
Location
bangalore
As the dedate is on and will go on forever between LCD and Plasma, just to check the reality on which technology is being sold mostly lets have the poll.

well if u are talking about sales ,its around 2 years since lcd took over lead in sales.
 

Dushie

New Member
Joined
Apr 9, 2007
Messages
1,676
Points
0
Location
Bangalore
Personally i won't go on whatever is being sold more, as with the right marketing style u can even sell junk to people.
In india people just enter a shop and buy lcd, cause the shopkeeper recommends. There are very few users who dig deep before making buying decisions.


Technology, price , quality and picture wise Plasma is the best and beat's lcd any day. If you don't have one check out the picture at any one who owns one and you will understand what i mean. For home theater where u want screen sizes upto 50" plasma rocks.

Below 40" will recommend to go for Lcd as u don't get may plasma models at that price though u have few 37" models ....
 

adder

Well-Known Member
Joined
May 1, 2008
Messages
2,571
Points
83
Location
bangalore
Personally i won't go on whatever is being sold more, as with the right marketing style u can even sell junk to people.
In india people just enter a shop and buy lcd, cause the shopkeeper recommends. There are very few users who dig deep before making buying decisions.


Technology, price , quality and picture wise Plasma is the best and beat's lcd any day. If you don't have one check out the picture at any one who owns one and you will understand what i mean. For home theater where u want screen sizes upto 50" plasma rocks.

Below 40" will recommend to go for Lcd as u don't get may plasma models at that price though u have few 37" models ....

well not all people go by blindly and why do u think lcd has taken over the lead, 2 years ago lcds were the ones which were more expensive,yet they have gained the market lead.
now about plasma beating lcds any day i doubt that it depends on ur application and which lcd u compare to a plasma.

so my suggestion to the person who made this thread if u are primarly going to see SD content get urself a plasma(only because it has a lower resolution),but if u are going to use it for HD well the lcds does have the resolution advantage compared to a normal plasma that has 1024x768,and there is no comparision to a FHD lcd or plasma which has about 3 times the resolution.
now in a 42inch plasma like panasonic PV8 it will have about 1044 pixels/square inch of display area,compared to a 40inch HD lcd which has 1533 pixels/ square inch which is roughly 50% more pixels and a 40inch FHD lcd or FHD plasma will have approx 3035 pixels/sq inch that is nearly 300% more pixels/ sq inch which means u can see the fine details and the image will be more sharp in a FULL HD LCD or FHD PLASMA when fed a FHD signal.

now todays lcd have greatly improved contrast levels and black levels like lcd from sony and samsung models exceed the contrast levels produced by many plasma like panasonic PV8,and have equaly good black levels and some models have ever better black levels then PV8.some people might say "look the contrast levels of plasma are 15000:1 etc that is bull.
the best of the plasma produce only about 3600:1 which are expensive like the pioneer kuro and panasonic PY800H which is yet to be launched in india and no doubt be quite expensive,but plasma like panasonic PV8 make a contrast about 1800:1.
lcds like sony S,V,W series and samsung series 5,6 have a contrast anywhere b/w 1800 like samsung series 5 to 2500:1 for sony W series,V series make a contrast about 2300:1.
newer lcds like samsung series 8 make a contrast of 3000:1.

now newer lcd from samsung like series 8 and sony,toshiba have one of the best image processing tech that does a good job in upscaling a SD content.
well if u are going to use it for gaming lcds are a safer choice dont have to worry about BURN IN.also FHD plasma are no better for viewing SD content.

finaly go take a look urself and then decide, take a laptop or ps3 and check out hd capabilities were lcd shine.
if its only SD content get a plasma like PV8 for HD content sony V series and samsung series 5 are good VFM.
 

Shuvc

Active Member
Joined
May 8, 2007
Messages
316
Points
28
Location
Calcutta
This poll should have checkbox options instead of radio buttons. There are people who have both Plasmas and LCDs at home.
 

anuragn

Active Member
Joined
Aug 24, 2008
Messages
489
Points
28
Location
Navi Mumbai
some people might say "look the contrast levels of plasma are 15000:1 etc that is bull.
the best of the plasma produce only about 3600:1 which are expensive like the pioneer kuro and panasonic PY800H which is yet to be launched in india and no doubt be quite expensive,but plasma like panasonic PV8 make a contrast about 1800:1.
What is the source of this info?

And the resolutions are not per sq inch, they are for the full screen.
 

psychotropic

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jul 19, 2008
Messages
2,832
Points
83
Location
Chennai, India
one more opportunity for the debate to start again :) the LCDs outsell Plasmas by a long way. But this does not suggest that LCDs are better than Plasmas. A lot of it has to do with marketing. Most videophiles continue to prefer the picture on Plasma. Recently a magazine conducted a comparison shootout between the best plasma on the market and the best LCD....i've forgotten which one, if someone can dig up this link, I would be grateful....they concluded that while the pictures are very very close....the Plasma has a slight edge. Even the people who regularly review TVs including the people at CNET (who get a lot of stick i don't know why, because they do more systematic reviews of TVs than most others) continue to reiterate that Plasmas give superior pictures compared to LCDs.

The statement that Plasmas have lower resolution is false. 1080p plasmas are widely available, albeit more expensive than their HD Ready counterparts. At the size that most people are going to buy TVs 32 - 42" this difference is mostly academic.

But of course there are many arguments in favour of LCDs as well (not to mention many photographs ;) ) ....which is why I am restraining myself and saying that I won't post any more on this thread, as it can go on endlessly!
 

selective

Member
Joined
Oct 6, 2008
Messages
36
Points
6
Location
Bangalore
Guys,

I started this thread just for reality check and not on to debate which technology is better. Everyone has their own reasons to opt for one of these TVs. So let us not continue debating all over it again, as we have spent enough bandwidth and pages on that.

-Selective.
 

bhuvanmisra

Member
Joined
Aug 25, 2008
Messages
150
Points
18
Location
Pune, India
the poll must also provide "crt" as an option to get the real picture of how many are looking to upgrade to flat panel displays
 
Top