Ive been thinking about the role of Bollywood on music in India. I think Bollywood is a blessing in promoting music industry in India and curse for advancing music in India.
Unfortunately music business has been run like a mafia, more or less like rest of the film industry in Bombay. There are more problems that can be fixed with this system.
Music and its gatekeepers. There are a select few in power and control in Bollywood. Be it the artist to perform, or the style of music etc, there are a few people who have the authority to decide the course of music as far as India is concerned. In the past this was controlled by music directors, now it's controlled by music directors and producers. Music producers in Bollywood are stuck with what seems to work (formula) and don't want to experiment with new artists, styles, compositions and genres. Their interest is in being relevant by regurgitating and copying music that has worked before.
Music and Bollywood. Producers don't care about the music,. It's just a tool to get more audience in the cinema. If they could get 2 goats each other on screen they will do that instead. The main purpose of music now in a movie is to get screen time on youtube and TV/radio. as I said, 2 goats......
Music and money. There is tons money in Bollywood. But is there is money in music in India or it has to survive on leftover of of Bollywood? There have been a few artists who have broken the mould and started with Bollywood and moved to main mainstream (if there's mainstream in India apart from Bollywood). They are still famous because of Bollywood and have to remain relevant by aligning with the film industry. They are performing the same old Bollywood songs when they are not singing in a wedding for money. It's still rather difficult to survive in India as an independent artist.
Music and TV. Shows like Indian Idol have done more damage to the music industry in India than befitted it. They are the same gatekeepers as the judges and their interest is not in getting the best artist but the best sellable artist. They still want the contestants to sing the same old Bollywood songs (with a slight twist), touch their feet and ask for blessings (to sing just like they did!). It feeds their ego's and their interest is in promoting themselves and not the contestants. The TV producers only care about the ratings and ad revenue. They want more drama than music! The whole music contest TV industry is churning boring, predictable imitators, not artists or musicians.
Music and Audience. we have an overkill of music in India. It's everywhere, and not just there, its in your face! Its blaring from an old radio at every paan shop, a new streaming device speaker at your favorite hairdresser or grocery store. Its everywhere! It's fatiguing to listen to just this amount of good or bad music. We are hearing music but are not listening to it as there is just so much of it. Most of us don't have the luxury to invest in a good Hi-Fi, interest in music to need one, and the time to make use of it. Mist of our countrymen and women are pretty happy with the music being fed to them than developing the time, interest and money to invest in it. We are happier with youtube and facebook feeds than look for music on spotify and apple music.
I think the combination of Bollywood and its role in influencing the public to sell cinema and lack of opportunities for independent artists is slowing the advancement of music in India. Any thoughts?
Unfortunately music business has been run like a mafia, more or less like rest of the film industry in Bombay. There are more problems that can be fixed with this system.
Music and its gatekeepers. There are a select few in power and control in Bollywood. Be it the artist to perform, or the style of music etc, there are a few people who have the authority to decide the course of music as far as India is concerned. In the past this was controlled by music directors, now it's controlled by music directors and producers. Music producers in Bollywood are stuck with what seems to work (formula) and don't want to experiment with new artists, styles, compositions and genres. Their interest is in being relevant by regurgitating and copying music that has worked before.
Music and Bollywood. Producers don't care about the music,. It's just a tool to get more audience in the cinema. If they could get 2 goats each other on screen they will do that instead. The main purpose of music now in a movie is to get screen time on youtube and TV/radio. as I said, 2 goats......
Music and money. There is tons money in Bollywood. But is there is money in music in India or it has to survive on leftover of of Bollywood? There have been a few artists who have broken the mould and started with Bollywood and moved to main mainstream (if there's mainstream in India apart from Bollywood). They are still famous because of Bollywood and have to remain relevant by aligning with the film industry. They are performing the same old Bollywood songs when they are not singing in a wedding for money. It's still rather difficult to survive in India as an independent artist.
Music and TV. Shows like Indian Idol have done more damage to the music industry in India than befitted it. They are the same gatekeepers as the judges and their interest is not in getting the best artist but the best sellable artist. They still want the contestants to sing the same old Bollywood songs (with a slight twist), touch their feet and ask for blessings (to sing just like they did!). It feeds their ego's and their interest is in promoting themselves and not the contestants. The TV producers only care about the ratings and ad revenue. They want more drama than music! The whole music contest TV industry is churning boring, predictable imitators, not artists or musicians.
Music and Audience. we have an overkill of music in India. It's everywhere, and not just there, its in your face! Its blaring from an old radio at every paan shop, a new streaming device speaker at your favorite hairdresser or grocery store. Its everywhere! It's fatiguing to listen to just this amount of good or bad music. We are hearing music but are not listening to it as there is just so much of it. Most of us don't have the luxury to invest in a good Hi-Fi, interest in music to need one, and the time to make use of it. Mist of our countrymen and women are pretty happy with the music being fed to them than developing the time, interest and money to invest in it. We are happier with youtube and facebook feeds than look for music on spotify and apple music.
I think the combination of Bollywood and its role in influencing the public to sell cinema and lack of opportunities for independent artists is slowing the advancement of music in India. Any thoughts?
Last edited by a moderator: