Video Processors vs HTPC

Subscibe to HiFiMART Newsletter

Tuhin Lavania

Active Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2018
Messages
266
Points
43
Location
Ankleshwar, Gujarat
Hello Guys,
Im confused which one to get. A Video processor like the MadVR Envy / Lumagen ( 5348 mostly ) or a HTPC with a 3080 or a 3090 ( most probably ) card.

Now i need external video processing for basically two things.
1. Tone Mapping for HDR
2. Aspect Ratio detection

For the first one, i have the NX 7 which does a very good job of tone mapping HDR content but i hear/read a lot of people saying the DTM done by the Envy and the Lumagen is way ahead of what the onboard processing of the JVC provides. I have never seen both working together, personally to see the difference but ive seen the pictures and yeah it might not be a great idea to figure differences by seeing pictures but still there is a lot of difference.

For the second, which is the most important one, i have a 2.35 screen. Now 16:9 movies are a pain to watch on this screen. I need something that can fill the entire 2.35 screen without any image spillage outside the screen, thus fitting the screen perfectly. Now i know this takes a slight hit in the resolution but thats fine for me. It can be resolved by adding a DCR lens but thats later.

These two factors are important for me while purchasing a Video processor. Now i want to know if this can be resolved easily with the help of a HTPC running a MadVR software. I know the HTPC can do DTM but can it do Auto Aspect Ratio detection like the Lumagen or the Envy easily ?

I prefer to buy a PC as it will be cheap and can be used as a Gaming machine. I can get a 3090 or a 3080 and thats good enough. Im out of PC scene since 11 years now and i game on consoles now but want to switch back to PC. ( Doom Eternal made me want a PC so much )
A HTPC will be cumbersome to use for the above said factors, but im saving a lot of money by not going for a dedicated video processor. And the main question is, how much tough is using a HTPC compared to a Video processor ?

Any inputs, please.
Thank You.
 

altaf9600

New Member
Joined
Aug 1, 2021
Messages
2
Points
1
Location
mumbai
hi i am altaf from mumbai. i have been using htpc with mpc hc and madvr for a year now. came to this forum for research and help on some issues. if u need any help pls message me
<deleted contact details.. Pls use DM>

by the way i frogot to tell you that even i am a proud owner of jvc nx7
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Top