Hi,
Cranky Thanks First off for the support and such that you are offering !! will surely ask if I need any !!
Now Please Excuse me for the following
!
My first question was the basis for rejection of established brand offerings and the subsequent claim that your offering was superior.
Have you read my post properly ???
,if so could you please highlight or repeat it so that I can correct it or clarify or throw some light on it !!
In no part of my post have I said anything bout
mine being superior or claimed a single damn thing !! So I request you to Kindly refrain from making such comments as this gives a wrong impression to others !!
So in a sense, what specific claims are you making, both in technical and marketing terms, that positions your offering above those from these vendors.
Again I absolutely have no idea/clue as to where you got this impression !! if have a knack of reading between the lines and make statements based on them,then Am sorry cannot help you ! but otherwise Let me Clarify,
I Have NO CLAIMS !! My tweeter is or will be a DIY effort which has some hopes of achieving certain things, whether it'll come through or not is another thing which I will talk at the appropriate time, Now is not the time !
Mine Might be the shittest/worst/most mediocre (please feel free to add on
) tweeter that has ever came out on this face of earth ! but even if its the other way/viceversa still its mine and
I claim nothing !
What I said is,they offered no VFM (yes this I have claimed) and I will still stick with it !! to me a what I pay for and what I get in return should be equal or atleast justifiable this VFM to me (will not add anything else as its different debate altogether as to what constitutes to VFM for which individual) ! now what this means to others is of no consequence to me !! this is my personal view and Am entitled to one !!
that positions your offering above those from these vendors.
Similarly Who said anything about makerting them ??? atleast not me
! Am making this for my own damn sake,so NO Selling, No Marketing,No Nothing !!!
I've made this clear on second post replying to Gobble
!!
Anyways Hope I've cleared the Doubts
!
Ok so thats done with Now lets get on with the business,
With large excursions like 1mm and 600Fs, you're aiming for a pretty large dome/VC which might then run into dispersion issues higher up the range, unless you make it concentric/ring-dome with two radiating surfaces (and end up with combing).
Well what you say might be true,But thats why I have devised some solutions for keeping VC small (as in regular 25MM) and still achieving the goal (may be harder then said
but will give it a shot ) which I have mentioned in the reply ! one the second point yes it seems so,as one single dome unit may not work ! thats why I have a hybrid dome,its a titanium with silk !! the outer ring or the surround (like the one in a regular driver) is of silk with a roll (to freely move) and in the inner or the main thing is titanium ! so this though strictly cannot be called Dual Concentric but still somewhat works on the similar lines hence is opted !
This will help it mate to almost all midwoofers upto 7" without any issues, and should be fine with even 8 inch woofers and a slightly lower XO point for reduced power handling, as long as the distortion is not too much (below -40dB is normally good enough).
Well thats the Idea Buddy
! I want this dome to work with most of the midbass driver available so that I don't have to break my head with matching them and taming them a higher slope crossover and Blah Blah Blah.......
It will be much tougher to cross over low and maintain phase integrity across the band.
Well let me just check and see where I end up
!
On excursion I would say 1mm is too much, even 0.5mm should be enough but I trust you will put in a few runs with both to see what kind of power handling you can get out of your speaker with both excursions, as well as distortion results. Again, I would be very happy with something that maintained its composure with about 30 watts @1.5KHz and about 50 @2KHz. More is usually not needed, I'm assuming your tweeter will have at least 88dB/W sensitivity.
Point noted let me see if I reduce the Xmax where will I end up with respect to Fs and overall SQ !! Yup most certainly will test it and share the results
! also as I earlier mentioned I have too many dome units to try and not all of them are capable of 1MM ! so its just a matter of changing the dome unit in the same motor and seeing the result ! as with the Sensitivity Am also hoping it to be in the same range of 88-90dB !
Are you planning quantity manufacturing or limited contract runs?
Last but certainly not the least, Once again, Sir I have
no Plans to commercialise this as of now !!
Having said that I will most defiantly consider your request and offer you a pair to play ! But first let me have a successful run (as in complete ) of the prototype's with all the R&D's
! Then surely will let you know !!
Regards.