Tower Speakers - Budget increased

olly42

Active Member
Joined
Jan 4, 2011
Messages
863
Points
43
Location
India
Hi Friends

In my last post I was trying to get a VFM for Tower speakers for a budget of 20k. And did not find anything good enough.So I have decided to increase my total budget to 45 K but now need to include a good AVR as well

Need your valuable suggestions - Thank You in advance
 
I was to go to Audio Planet to audition Mortant Short and Monitor Speakers but the rain played spoil sport and will be going there tomorrow hopefully. Mr Pallani is a very busy man :)
 
Hi Friends

In my last post I was trying to get a VFM for Tower speakers for a budget of 20k. And did not find anything good enough.So I have decided to increase my total budget to 45 K but now need to include a good AVR as well

Need your valuable suggestions - Thank You in advance

I was referring to that. If you specify what you found lacking in those s[eakers, members could help you better on what you could try in your new budget.
 
Hi All,

Auditioned the Polk/Kef/Wharfedale speakers today

Polk - TSi 400 - Really liked the midrange and Bass of these speakers. As of now I dont intend to add a Sub to my 5.1 and the sound suited my requirement. Amp used was Denon 2311. I want to audition TSi 500 before I close in on the speakers

Polk RTI A7 - Found them to be softer in comparison to the TSi 400. Again the amp used was Denon 2311. Not sure if my hearing ok lol. I keep reading that the Rti scores over the TSi -

Used soundtracks/video from Lagaan, Jodha Akbar, Eagles, Some western Classical. The sound effects of TSi 400 was awesome. But then it was a complete 5.1 set :)

Wharfedale 10.7 /9.6 again similar situation found the 9.6 better than the 10.7 Maybe and just maybe the cost is sending the wrong signals to my brain and somehow making me feel that the older models sound better

Well have mixed feelings so far - got to audition Monitor M4/Monitor RS6 and Mordaunt short speakers soon before the plunge is taken

So far with the exceeded budget I am thinking of picking Denon AVR 1911 and Polk TSi 500. Now I know that I am way over board. I will be selling of my HK AVR 133 along with my Surrounds shortly. So hope to bridge the gap somehow

Somehow I dont feel like letting go of my Jamo S416 Towers so i am just wondering and this may be a total no no but can I use the Jamo towers in place of the surrounds?

Please advise
 
olly42,
What's the price quoted to you for the Polk Tsi 400 - How much for the pair of FS and then how much for the entire 5.1 setup?

I might be taking its demo tomorrow...
And how much for the Wharfedale 9.6 FS pair?

I am also in the market for speakers and hence checking out the options....
 
Snorkel4u,

The quote I got today where all MRP rates and will get the final rates by Monday. Will be more than glad to share them with you and all on this wonderful Forum
 
Olly, Retaining your Jamo Towers for surround duty imho is unnecessary/overkill.
Have you auditioned the Acoustic Energy floorstanders? If not try the Aegis Neo 3, its in your budget. The MA RS6 is another good option,pricier though. It is a bit difficult to find as the rx6 has replaced it.
Another option is the Usher V601 series. Where are you located? Contact ARN/Odeyssey on this forum to find where you can audition it.
You can also have a look at the Audire Callistos, though I am not exactly sure how they will pair with the Denon AVR.
 
Hi iaudio,

I am located in Bangalore. Will surely visit ARN/Odeyssey to audition the speakers you mentioned

I am just trying to make amends with the impulsive purchases I have made with the HK AVR133 prior to joining this forum. I have to make many adjustments to make these changes :( but now there is no backing out :) So valuable inputs from all of you would make things easier. I have no plans to upgrade once these purchases are done. So I have to be very careful about every step I take
 
Hi Friends,

How are Polk Audio Monitor 70 Tower Speakers? I have never shopped on Ebay is it safe to procure speakers from US Please advice

Thank You
 
iaudio,

If I buy better towers HK 133 wont match up with them


Harman Kardon receivers are better then many receivers available in the market today. I think there is no need to change the AVR at this point of time. Try sourcing a good speaker and try with HK 133. If you dont like it , then go for other models. Also try the Marantz 5005, they are very good receiver and good for both music and movie.

regards
 
+1 to what Soundofmusic has said. Why have you concluded that your HK wont match with better speakers?
Forget about ordering from US, unless you have heard the same speakers with your AVR. You do not want to make a mistake buying blind, unless you have some strong hunch/logic.

Carry your AVR when you go audition those speakers and then make a final decision.
 
Now that you are back on auditions , why dont you carry your HK and see what speakers will pair well with it? . I know its a pain carrying the AVR to every place , but considering the amount of money you will save after finding a perfect pair of speakers , pretty sure its worth the effort. Unless you are thinking to move away from AVR and buy a stereo amp to drive the FS ... :)
 
Hi Soundofmusic/iaudio/Kittu,

I appreciate your inputs. I am definitely in no hurry to make these purchases in a haste and I will take your valuable advise. I am going to carry my AVR to all these auditions and will update the forum accordingly

Thank You
 
You increased the budget to 45k but included AVR. That actually leaves you with just about the same budget for speakers.

M advise would be to upgrade speakers and later on AVR or wait for some more time. Do you really need FS? or BS may suffice. Dont upgrade in a manner that you are in market soon again.
 
You increased the budget to 45k but included AVR. That actually leaves you with just about the same budget for speakers.

M advise would be to upgrade speakers and later on AVR or wait for some more time. Do you really need FS? or BS may suffice. Dont upgrade in a manner that you are in market soon again.

TaureanBull I am taking all these inputs and will act accordingly :)
Thank You
 
You increased the budget to 45k but included AVR. That actually leaves you with just about the same budget for speakers.

My advise would be to upgrade speakers and later on AVR or wait for some more time. Do you really need FS? or BS may suffice. Dont upgrade in a manner that you are in market soon again.
I second that.
Seriously...that is not the kind of money with which you should be looking at towers. No way will you be satisfied!!! You might be satisfied 'at the moment of it', but you are highly likely to back shopping soon for want of better. You can do pretty well with a BS instead, for that money. To get hold of a decent entry level FS which delivers really good quality music...that keeps you happy for a long while...you shd have a budget of *at least* 50K for the towers alone, in fact a bit more can fetch you much better. Anything lesser for towers, you wud be left lacking. Again, it might sound good initially, but you will get a 'hollow feeling' after a few weeks. We humans have a short acoustic memory, so everything comparable to some extend tends to sound good to some extend. But when you listen to them for prolonged periods, one can start to sense if it is lacking or not. Buy a good pair of front speakers, and you might not shop again for fronts for 15-20 years (even higher if you can maintain it well..unless you are an audioholic or spendthrift).

Few questions you shd ask yourself is,
1. What is the price to performance that you achieve. Is it worth to spend 'X' to achieve 'Y'?
2. Do you have an audioholic ear, that helps you notice the small differences in some speakers. Wud you be so particular about little differences? If not you might need to consider 'point (1)' even more carefully.
3. Do you need to listen to dealers and their suggestions, whose job is to sell. They might sound very convincing. But look at it again from perspective of (1).
4. Should you blindly take advice from people about 'which speakers'? Consult multiple forums and from different places to have a better and more reliable idea, not that one forum wont be reliable. It need not be always reliable.

When there is this urge to buy something once & you feel like buying it, will be very difficult to go back. You should take some time, save up. Buy a good pair of fronts and expand slowly if you desire to, but dont compromise on quality. You could be back shopping no time spending more money. Also 50K or so is a lot of money. Spend it carefully. Dont get carried away by what you read. Ppl will always tend to give you advice like this is a good choice or that is great stuff (Which is not be a bad thing from their perspective). Also, if you observe a lotta people tend to say in an implicit if not explicit way that... 'my stuff is good', and 'the other ones are okie'. But when they are back shopping for new stuff, their good stuff is not so gud suddenly..anymore :).
One also tends to hear positive stuff more often than not, and tend to ignore negative comments unless it is big and explicit kinds.
Most guys wud not want to admit that they feel something is lacking with their stuff while they actually feel it is lacking in the corner of their mind. It takes time until they decide to shop, and then you hear 'this and that is lacking' or 'I want better now'. Why would you go for in search of better if you were happy in the first place. :D The thought of buying something wud not even cross their busy minds unless it is lacking or they just realized it is lacking :).
...and am sure you know this pretty well by your own experience. Question is, have you observed it until now ;)
 
Last edited:
Hi,

You can look at Onkyo 508 (26K) + HTS-728, total should come to 47-48K after discounts.

OR, you can take onkyo 308/508 and combine with MS Aviano 6 speakers, they are very good.
 
Get the Award Winning Diamond 12.3 Floorstanding Speakers on Special Offer
Back
Top