Anyone udated their existing old bookshelf speakers?

Fantastic

Well-Known Member
Joined
Jun 1, 2010
Messages
831
Points
93
Location
Third Rock
This can be quite an interesting thing to do to an old speaker. I say that because if it's old and you ruin it you won't feel so bad as compared to a new unit ! I'm however a habitual offender!:) All new systems must be opened for inspection !
First thing to do would be to inspect the crossover and use better /modern parts. All capacitors could be replaced with better types.All inductors could be made air core if possible. Wire wound resistors could be changed to non inductive types. One would need to open up the system to know what type of parts would benefit from a change .

This could be a challenge. Some crossovers are soldered to the input sockets and so just removing the rear connector panel will give access to the crossover. Otherwise the bass driver would need to be removed. If one is ham fisted it's better to avoid doing anything as you don't want to destroy a driver due to a clumsy attempt at removing them. A replacement could be very expensive or impossible ! Not to mention the damage you can do to the cabinet surface by using careless procedures.

Note that the speaker could be converted to a bi-wireable system if it wasn't already so. You can also strengthen the cabinet walls with cross braces and do some panel damping with adhesive dense felt.

Is it all worth the trouble ? I can say that it made a big difference to one of my older speakers. Some speakers might not benefit as much, as they would already be be using very good parts. But people not wanting to spend on a new speaker might get a better speaker by just upgrading their existing speaker.

You might also note that MOST small bookshelf speakers do not have much bass weight . The drivers are too small. It would be very helpful if an active crossover was used and a sub added. The performance of the bookshelf will increase very noticeably ( due to reduced LF activity) and you would be able to play louder and cleaner than before. Not to mention the overall increase in "power" due to the added sub.
 
Replacing all "wirewound" resistors and inductors indescrimately is not recommended. As the cross-over frequency/slope may be shifted. As sometimes, designers take the so called inductance also in to consideration. Same is the case with Inductors. When changing the inductors, the DC resistance of the inductors have to be kept in mind as it may have been considered in crossover design. Changing it again could change the cross-over frequency/slope.
 
Has anyone actually measured the inductance on a "wirewound" resistor? According to me it will be in microHenries. Will this cause a theoretical sonic difference? Yes. Will the difference be audible? That is a million $ Q and I think not unless maybe you're a bat [the mammal].

OTOH, has anyone measured the inductance on a "non-inductive" resistor? No inductance?
 
Last edited:
OTOH, has anyone measured the inductance on a "non-inductive" resistor? No inductance?

All conductors will have self-inductance, and includes leads, pads, PCB traces, etc. It's measurable, and runs from about 5-10 nH per centimetre for typical FR4 PCB laminate, depending on trace width, thickness, etc. It's similar for conductive leads in free space.

A typical non-inductive resistor will therefore have ~ 10 nH of lead inductance, and a smaller bulk inductance.

It's not likely to make any difference to audible sonics in most applications *except* a few critical feedback, filter and bridge-balance circuits. That includes the Howland Current Pump used in several nested chipamp circuits, and the Quad reactive-bridge used in the Quad-606 and similar power amplifiers, where a few 10s of nH in lead inductance on the resistive legs can displace the balance of a reactive bridge which has only ~1 uH on the inductive leg. The DC resistance of that leg is also critical.
 
2nd Video Clip
Recorded Sound is different from the original.
Now the sound is better than before (still tuning)

Last Saturday, one of my friend came and listened to the sound.
He is a one of music lover who guides me into music world.
He gave more marks than mine.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H3Kk64P05eQ#t=38
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Wharfedale Linton Heritage Speakers in Walnut finish at a Special Offer Price. BUY now before the price increase.
Back
Top